The Milleridge Inn

Went for a friends Christmas party, some of my party had an issue at the bar, being overcharged for happy hour drinks, service was nice but slow, Carolers to request from our table and sang, very festive. I got a breadless Brigade Eggplant sandwich. It was fine but portion was small. Someone else got the price fixed Yankee Pot Roast dinner which came with soup and dessert. It was tasty as was the bowl of mushroom soup.

My party of 3 ordered a variety of food for dinner & each one was happy with their meal. One problem- the bread is so delicious I started to get full. Similar to when I was in Italy. The atmosphere is very festive with the Milleridge village right there to shop for the holidays or get something from the delicious bakery. The service was good but I felt that the waitress came over too many times & I felt that she was trying to get us out. Now there were plenty of tables available including a table for 4 which we were at. The restaurant was not ready to close either so I don’t understand her behavior unless she felt that was giving extra special service. Nevertheless we had a great time & I will be back there in a little over a month with my friends again (I live in Suffolk County or I would go more often) I highly recommend this restaurant & particularly around the holidays with all the decorations.

We went for dinner and were truly impressed by the beauty of the place. Each room has its own charm, and walking through them while reading about the history was a great experience. As for the food; it was just okay. I’d give it 1 out of 5 stars if you’re going for the meals alone. If you’re expecting a flavorful or standout dining experience, this may not be the right spot. That said, their drinks, cinnamon bread, French fries, pork chops, and mac and cheese were all surprisingly delicious and worth trying, but the rest of the food was 1 star.

great food in a historic setting with wonderful service, we ate here after going to the events at the haunted village and truly enjoyed our meal

I attended a pre Mother’s Day brunch event held for the ladies of LICOA on May 4, 2025. The event catered to approximately 80 people in my party and it was run decidedly very well. The ambiance of the facility was quite unique, and lent a fine old Long Island country flair. It was rather classy if I must say! The food… oh the food…. It was absolutely delicious! They’re were several, at least two omelette stations, a cold cheese and salad spread, nice assortment of fresh cut fruits, another generous area of hot lunches serving a divine lamb stew, yummy chicken franchise, hot pasta dishes, an array of cold and hot seafood such as shrimp cocktail, king crab legs, oysters and the works! The desert spread included a variety of sliced cakes, cannoli, pastries, brownies, cookies, cobblers and pies etc. Needless to say I sampled the goodies and it did not disappoint my tastebuds! This fine catering facility, The Milleridge Inn here on Long Island has for sure made my list of superb, well run establishments. I’ll certainly be coming back here very soon! The staff were attentive, friendly and very accommodating. For such a large crowd in my event, taking into consideration that there was also another event, a baby shower being held in another section, we never felt neglected in service in any way. Parking… there was plenty and more than ample parking. The lot is huge. As for wheelchair accessibility, it surely is, I saw a ramp when you entered the front doors so that makes for easy entry with a wheelchair. This facility is also family and kid friendly. I highly recommend The Milleridge Inn for all of your catering needs! Its location is perfect of any event from weddings, to baby showers and dinners to brunches. 06/15/25~Response to Owner: Thanks for the kind words! I’m happy to support local businesses like yours.

Went in late November, it was all decorated for Christmas which I loved, very cozy, was able to sit in front of fireplace. They give you a warm cinnamon bread before your meal which was amazing! I ordered the French onion soup which had so much cheese just the way I like it, we shared a roast sandwich to share and I’m glad we did because it was big with fries. They also have a bar and sitting area. Big parking lot, they had a Christmas village but only open on weekends which was a shame, I would have loved to get a coffee and pastry shop around and get some unique gifts

Super cute and very festive. The best part was all the peacocks.